Equity Management Counterarguments

A few weeks ago I made the claim that equity managent was not what it’s craked out to be. I also wrote a post on AgentGenius.com (a national real estate magazine) that equity management is overrated. I can’t say these articles have caused a firestorm, but proponents have come out and made some really good rebuttals.

Yesterday, Robert Ashby wrote that equity management is misunderstood and made a very good case on the other side. He breaks down my arguments point by point and presents a very good set of counter arguments. As someone who has personally practiced the principles he is very well positioned to provide some insights.

… as one who practices equity management myself and has provided many families mortgage plans that are helping them meet their financial goals by using their mortgage as a tool, I have to disagree with it being overrated.  The bottom line, as I see it, is equity management can help anyone, regardless of what the markets are doing since it is centered around the individuals financial goals and dreams.

Don’t forget to read the comments in these pots. Some industry heavy hitters like Jeff Brown and Brian Brady provide some really good counter arguments as well.  Not quite a juicy firestorm, but it’s an educational experience for anyone curious about equity management!

Equity Managment Is Not What It’s Cracked Out To Be

Yes. I said it. And I said it right here on my blog. And I’ll say it again. Equity management is not what it’s cracked out to be and today’s mortgage market bears that out beautifully. Why is this a big deal? Well, because within our industry anyone who does not believe in equity management strategy is considered a dinosaur. The thinking is that equity management is the wave of the future and takes into consideration the evolved mortgage landscape.

To be honest with you, personally and as a mortgage professional, I have never felt comfortable with equity management. The enthusiasm that I hear about equity management reminds me of the “new economy” arguments of the late 1990s. And we all know how those companies turned out don’t we? Pets.com anyone? “Because pets can’t drive”.

In an article at AgentGenius (I’m a guest writer for this national Real Estate blog), I outline four reasons why I think equity management is overrated. Here is a summary of the four reasons:

1. What happens if you mortgage yourself to the hilt and then the real estate market crashes? Oh wait that may have just happened to a few folks.

2. I’ve read surveys which show that a major event happens in a person’s life every three to four years. Now if you’re trapped in a 100% interest only mortgage within a flat real estate market, things don’t look too rosy, do they?

3. It has also been found that people do not stay in a mortgage for more than four years and in a house for more than seven years. I believe the best way to ensure your mobility is equity in your home.

4. Finally, this strategy simply doesn’t work for folks on tight budgets, erratic spending patterns, those with credit card debt etc.

Bottom line is I can’t play dice with the roof over my child’s head. I am confident that I can create wealth without compromising the asset that holds the key to everything about my future. Plain and simple. Irrational? Maybe? But wise? I think so.

Read “Equity Management is Overrated” at AgentGenius.com for my full take.

Second Homes Do Not Qualify For Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief

An AMG reader asks (there was no e-mail since it came from the Plugoo application):

If debt is forgiven on a second home under construction, but never occupied does it qualify for the forgiveness of debt? Homeowner purchased second home – was going to move into it upon completion.

Second homes do not qualify for the mortgage forgiveness tax benefit President Bush signed late last year. Only primary residences under $2 million qualify. IRS section 121 defines what constitutes a principle residence. This forgiveness provision is not forever either, its only for mortgage debt forgiven in 2007, 2008 and 2009.

As anything with the tax code, the whole thing is pretty complex so consult a tax professional for the details. In the mean time Ilyce Glink’s blog has a great “Tax Help” section which discusses this very issue.