Mortgage Insurance vs. Second Liens

I attended a presentation today on Mortgage Insurance. The presenter was pretty excited since she believed MI would be making a strong comeback this year. She gave several reasons for this, one of them being the fact that MI is now tax deductible.

I challenged her on the tax deductibility part since the provision only allows tax deductibility for 2007 and for individuals with less than $100,000 annual income. While the income part may cover most people, the fact that it is only available for loans taken in 2007 is cause for worry. However, the presenter strongly felt that this would be renewed for 2008 and beyond.

The second point made by the presenter had to do with the subprime crash and the subsequent effect it has had on seconds liens. For borrowers in the lower credit score range second liens have become very expensive. We are talking about a one to two percentage points increase in the rate. This can make the second mortgage substantially more expensive. MI can certainly look very attractive in this situation.

There are two methods of using MI in todays market. The first is borrower paid monthly MI. This is a monthly amount paid into an escrow account with monthly taxes and insurance. After the close, the borrower has the option to call the loan servicer to cancel this payment if the borrower has either paid down the principle quickly or, the loan to value has fallen to 80% of the house value by sheer home appreciation. A new appraisal is usually required, paid for by the borrower of course, and many servicer will not address the issue until at least two years after the transaction has closed. Different loan service companies have different rules on this so, check with your particular loan servicer for exact requirements.

The second method is the Lender Paid MI (LPMI) where the lender increases the rate by a certain percentage to cover the MI. The main argument against the LPMI is that the loan payment can never be reduced. However you have to remember that in a high loan to value situation it will be a long time before you reach less than 80% LTV anyways. So, if you are planning on being in the house for only a few years this can make good sense.

After the presentation I had a discussion with a Senior Loan Office at CTX Mortgage. (He has been a mentor figure in my career.) He has determined that Lender Paid MI (LPMI) is usually the better solution where the LTV is high and the borrower has a lower credit score. In the situation of lower LTV and higher credit score then monthly borrower paid MI may make sense but you have to make sure you find a competitive MI provider.

Every situation is different and there are many MI companies out there. To determine what is best for you, I suggest working with a good mortgage professional who understands the nuances of the different MI scenarios.

Welcome to the Arizona Mortgage Guru blog, a great resource for all your home financing needs. If you're new here and like the content, you can subscribe to my RSS feed to get regular updates on all things related to mortgages. Thanks for visiting.

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.