Private Mortage Insurance: The Adopted Step-Child Brings Home the Bacon

Back in August I had suggested that borrowers re-think the use of Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI) as they consider different home financing options. I pointed out that since PMI is tax-deductible for all purchases made in 2007 it is worth the consideration. Also with the demise of the 2nd lien market those fancy 80/20 and 80/15 loans aren’t as readily available anymore, so PMI could be the only option in many cases.

Looks like lots and lots of consumers read my post from August because the number of borrowers using PMI jumped 15.2%. According to PrivateMI.com:

Mortgage Insurance Companies of America (MICA) reports that 197,169 borrowers used private mortgage insurance (PrivateMI) to buy or refinance a home in August. The number of borrowers using PrivateMI in August was 15.2% higher than the July total of 171,186.

For all the years the mortgage insurance industry took a beating it’s making a strong comeback. At least for today PMI wins its battle with 2nd lien’s.

Re-thinking Private Mortgage Insurance

Over the past several years Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI) has gotten a bad name. There is a now a whole group of first time home buyers who think PMI is evil. That is because we mortgage pros have been placing everyone on these 80/20 deals. Don’t get me wrong, it makes a lot of sense to do an 80/20 loan instead of paying PMI. However, with the liquidity crisis spreading to second lien holders, obtaining a second loan instead of paying for PMI is no longer a slam dunk.

One of the main arguments for not using PMI was that it wasn’t tax deductible. This has now changed. At least for loans obtained in 2007 mortgage insurance will be tax deductible. Almost every company in the business I talk to says this deduction will almost certainly be extended. That I can’t say; but the argument for secondary financing is somewhat muted.

Also, many lenders offer lender paid mortgage insurance (LMPI) in exchange for a slightly higher interest rate. For a high loan to value (LTV) loan this can oftentimes make sense. The reason being that if you’re at 95% today it will be many years before you hit 80% and in that time you may move or re-finance the loan anyway. It then follows that paying a higher rate for LPMI makes sense. However, LPMI is not available to everyone, you must have good credit.

The mortgage market is in flux. The old rules of home financing are no long applicable. What made sense two months ago may no longer make sense. We are in a time where all options need to be on the table.

Hat/Tip to David Porter for his thoughtful comment on a recent post, which prompted me to write this.

What color is your service?

This last month has been a great month for me and my business. The reason being is that I have had multiple opportunities to engineer custom financing packages based on specific borrower needs. To me this is the hallmark of providing great service if you’re in the mortgage business.What color is your service?

What do I mean by this? Not all 30 year loans are the same. Not all loan features mean the same to every borrower. For example, a pre-payment penalty may be undesirable for a borrower flipping a condo, but ideal for reducing monthly payment for someone who intends to be in the home for 5 years. There are many considerations in the analysis and I’m not going to get into details. The bottom line is many people in our industry have preconceived impressions and do not think outside the box. In the long term both the originator and borrower lose!

It is amazing what you can do if you spend the proper time and put in the required effort. Recently I’ve been able to show a young couple the value of the 2-1 buy down and another one of the reasons why lender paid mortgage insurance makes sense in their situation. In the former, he would have lost out on a superb opportunity to own a home. In the latter case, she would have ended up overpaying by several hundred dollars in the coming years. Do you think these borrowers will ever regret doing business with me?

I go the extra mile while structuring the financing because first and foremost borrowers deserve it. They deserve to receive the best possible analysis on the market. The other reason I do this is because I enjoy thinking outside the box. After all, most Nepalese immigrants in the US are engineers or doctors, I’m in the mortgage business. I’ve always known that I’m a different breed.

Every originator I meet talks about how they provide service. Let’s face it, that has become the standard line in the industry. What is service? What color is your service? Mine is dark blue – the color of my financial calculator!